If the justice system has any real relationship with justice, shouldn’t it be able to do something about a hideous attorney-creature like New York’s Jeffrey T. Schwartz?

To call Mr. Schwartz despicable and inhumane would be an act of kindness and an insult to the words, despicable and inhumane. Mr. Schwartz is the defense attorney for Cesar Rodriquez, 29, who is on trial in Brooklyn’s Supreme Court for the murder of seven-year-old Nixzmary Brown. Nixzmary was found emaciated, beaten and dead on the floor or her Brooklyn home in January 2006. She weighed 36 pounds, barely half the weight of a healthy child her age.

Mr. Schwartz said in court that Mr. Rodriquez is a knight in shining armor because he took in Nixzmary, her five siblings and their mother after they’d been living in a homeless shelter. Never mind that Mr. Rodriquez told reporters in a jailhouse interview that he frequently beat Nixzmary. Nixzmary was beaten and held under icy water the day she died after the starving child helped herself to some yogurt.

The New York Times today captures the horror of the crime and the horror that is Mr. Schwartz when it said: “As for what Nixzmary did to provoke Mr. Rodriguez’s wrath on the last night of her life, Mr. Schwartz said, “It’s easy to say, ‘Aw, he killed the kid and beat her because of yogurt.’ Many of us don’t have yogurt problems” — here he gestured to his own well-fed midsection — “but when you’re poor and you can’t afford unlimited amounts of food and you have six children, you have to make sure that everyone gets what they’re entitled to get, so that you can ensure that everyone stays healthy.””

According to USA Today, Brooklyn police say “Cesar Rodriguez beat the little girl to death, then tossed her on the floor of what was known in the family’s apartment as the “dirty room,” a rodent-infested room where she had been tied up and left with only a litter box as a toilet.”
Mr. Schwartz said Nixzmary refused to be disciplined, pointing out that she would slip out of the ropes that tied her to the chair in the “dirty room”. “She was a little Houdini,” Mr. Schwartz said.

While I recoil at labeling of any group of people in society, I do think when it comes to the joke, “What do you call 100 lawyers at the bottom of the ocean? Answer: A good start,” Mr. Schwartz should be one of them. He certainly has no relationship with justice, much less human decency or a conscience. The New York Times reports that even the defendent Mr. Rodriquez looked visibly uncomfortable with Mr. Schwartz’s depiction of Nixzmary. When you’re upsetting the moral code of a child murderer, something’s very, very wrong.


  1. this is such specious, intellectual dishonesty.if you are honest enough to concede that this scumbag deserves a defense, how can you, in the same breath, fault the lawyer for doing his job? his job is to get the guy off the hook. period. unless mr schwartz violates the law, i dont care if he convinces the jury to acquit because aliens from ufo’s did it or because the kid was a little bastard who deserved her fate. that’s schwartz’s job. you have a problem with that- then for crying out loud, understand that your problem is with the system and the jury, not mr. schwartz. i fail to understand why that distinction is lost on so many people.


Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.